« Why emailing too deep can hurt your online fundraising | Main | Your instinct is wrong »

23 April 2012

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a0120a59ccea7970b0168ea988932970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference How personal opinions destroy fundraising effectiveness:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Jeff - This is great advice!

Of course we, as nonprofits, want to create a team environment in the office, but we've segmented our roles and responsibilities for a reason!

Let those who have a knack for directing first impressions, direct those impressions. Let those who have case-management skills, manage, inspire, and encourage the clients we serve. And let those who have experience in fundraising lead the team in creating systems of storytelling that invite people into the work that we love!

Thanks a lot for the post Jeff. It's definitely a thought-provoking piece. I agree that some are more qualified to weigh in or lead certain initiatives, but I'm struggling with the distinction between listening to an opinion and following each opinion giver's advice.

It seems to me that creating an environment where opinions can be freely shared can be very beneficial, even if it is not within someone's job description to do so. However, the decision to follow an opinion should be weighed and considered given the facts of the situation. Sure, some are more qualified. But some of the most innovative and unique ideas can come from those that aren't mired in the day to day of a given initiative and can view it with fresh eyes.

Again, thanks for sharing this post. Very thought-provoking for me.

Amen. Used to work for someone whose motto was "opinion above knowledge". It was sort of a joke, but... not really. It prompted me to blog on the subject, noting that to improve our fundraising and marketing communications we need to get inside the hearts and minds of our constituents..http://clairification.blogspot.com/2011/10/opinion-above-knowledge-common_24.html

I might add, however, that sometime a receptionist could have a more informed take on what our constituents care about than perhaps those in executive management. We often get trapped in old ways of thinking, especially if we've been around awhile.

Here’s what we know:
(1) People outside our organization DON’T think about it like we, our boss or our board do;
(2) We care more about our organization than our constituents do, and assume everyone else cares the same way we do;
(3) Advice acquired from random consultants and pundits is not the same as knowledge acquired from our 99%;
(4) Knowledge sourced directly from our constituents, via social media, is the best way to get a direct, real time, up-to-date read on what our community cares about and values
(5)We may be doomed to continue to put one bad foot in front of the next if we continue down the road of unsubstantiated opinion (anecdotes don’t count) above knowledge.

One of our clients used to ask their gardener what he thought of creative work. He used to preface all comments with "I don't give to charity but..."

It was presented to us as a challenge. If we crack him, we can crack everyone.

We never cracked him. Even when we did what he wanted.

We don't work with them any longer.

I find the original argument in this thread to lack substance. Aside from the fact that no information was given as to how said receptionist cost the organization "thousands of dollars", or how that figure was estimated, the argument provides a fundamental contradiction. IF "...the people who created it should and must ignore your opinion. It just doesn't matter to anyone but you." is true, THEN the following is not true: "Some people's opinions are positively deadly." And vice versa. I appreciate your argument, and understand how it could work, but without supporting evidence your post is also just another opinion.

The comments to this entry are closed.

What this blog is about
The future of fundraising is not about social media, online video, or SEM. It's not about any technology, medium, or technique. It's about donors. If you need to raise funds from donors, you need to study them, respect them, and build everything you do around them. And the future? It's already here. More.

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Subscribe with the reader of your choice
Subscribe
About the blogger
JeffJeff Brooks, creative director at TrueSense Marketing, has been serving the nonprofit community for more than 20 years and blogging about it since 2005. He considers fundraising the most noble of pursuits and hopes you'll join him in that opinion. You can reach him at jeff.brooks [at] truesense [dot] com. More.

Blog policies
TrueSense logo
Instead of talking at donors, TrueSense is proving it's smarter to listen. Asking donors how they prefer to give. Because we’re about creating relationships and building trust and communicating honestly and powerfully. One to one. Want to talk fundraising? Drop me a line.
Branding can boost fundraising

MoneyRaisingNonprofitBrand Is branding evil? Of course not. It only seems that way sometimes because it is so often wrongly applied to nonprofits.

Discover how to make branding improve your fundraising in The Money-Raising Nonprofit Brand: Motivating Donors to Give, Give Happily, and Keep on Giving. It's easier -- and less expensive -- than you may think! In this ground-breaking new book you'll find out...
  • Why commercial-style branding is so destructive when applied to nonprofits.
  • The 7 essential elements of a successful fundraising call to action that will motivate donors to give.
  • How to find and use images that remind donors why they care about your cause.
  • How to become your donors' favorite cause and set your organization apart in their hearts and minds.
If your organization is even vaguely considering "branding work," you need to read The Money-Raising Nonprofit Brand by Jeff Brooks. Read more here.
Irresistible fundraising!
TheFundraisersGuide Raise funds with your eyes open. Skip the guesswork. Show your boss what really works. This book takes you on a fact-filled and memorable journey through writing, design, strategy, and the mental game of effective fundraising.

Proven, tested, real-life techniques that give donors what they want so they can make the donations you need. If you care about fundraising, about your donors, and about supporting your cause, you need The Fundraiser's Guide to Irresistible Communications by Jeff Brooks. Order it today from Amazon.


Popular series

stupid nonprofit ads

Uncle Maynard's

Jeff's Inferno

Blog powered by Typepad