« Attack of the spokespersons and bad fundraising | Main | Fundraising creates meaning in donors' lives »

14 February 2013


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

I love love love this. Time and time again, I've seen flashy presentations gloss over core functionality needs when it comes to campaign and appeal structure. Fantastic post.

Oh man, so much gold in here. I have been to those presentations where envy is really the main point being communicated.

I'd love to see some presentation where the presenter says how they failed and what that taught them. 'Hey we did this awesome social media integration project and it got us jack squat. Turns out Social Media isn't that pot at the end of the rainbow.'

This article actually makes my heart hurt. I can only imagine folks who work for a smaller shop shrinking away in their chairs as someone with a pretty, expensive unless it's pro-bono)campaign leaves out the most important detail of all.

It's not fair/right/just to present failed campaigns as a model for success. In fact, it's just irresponsible and selfish.

Agree 100% - especially by the big commercial agencies that dazzle charities with all the big words and think getting donations must be easy!

We also do it ourselves though - SOFII shows a lot of case studies that talk about all the many elements that made up a an integrated campaign, but often fail to talk about the results.

Great post... I agree it's important to stick to the knitting as well as think outside the box but sometimes we do need creativity to stand out in these increasingly tough times, and integration sometimes to simply raise awareness and put ourselves on the radar of new audiences. So I completely agree that we need to be cautious of shiny attractive fancy things- unless - we are clear what they will deliver, we track, measure, test and report on everything and learn from mistakes.

I agree. Any campaign can only be judged on its success, and I often see award winning campaigns and think, slick but how much did it raise? If that question isn´t answered (or better still clearly stated as part of the presentation) may not be a model to follow. Also have to think about the bigger picture - sometimes campaigns don´t raise huge amounts of $$ initially but do raise the organisation/mission profile which brings benefits further down the line.

As our friend Brian Miller might say: "That's not entirely correct."

I have seen integrated campaigns succeed (and I have the data to prove it). I have also seen them fail.

As with most things in fundraising, it depends. In this case the variables are the nonprofit's market, the offer, media mix, frequency, reach and budget.

In an industry that really needs some innovation, I think we need to test and refine these ideas. We cannot afford to do it just once and say: "That didn't work."

Amen. One great thing about direct fundraising performance (unlike other media, marketing and advertising disciplines) is its practical measurability. Let's set aside arguments about the real fundraising value of "mission awareness" for a moment. If raising the mission profile does in fact bring benefits further down the line, let's document them, eh? Presumably metrics like retention, lifetime value, return on investment, gift frequency -- those "down the line" gains -- can be documented once known, out there for everyone to see. Until those metrics are known, the campaign needs to be presented with qualifiers that set expectations and perceptions correctly. Positioning the campaign as a best practice (without those qualifiers stated), which by inference is done at sessions such as the one Jeff cites, is irresponsible. I guess the larger question is: Why should an expectation of measurability be suspended in the name of innovation? Campaigns can't be innovative AND measurable?

The comments to this entry are closed.

What this blog is about
The future of fundraising is not about social media, online video, or SEM. It's not about any technology, medium, or technique. It's about donors. If you need to raise funds from donors, you need to study them, respect them, and build everything you do around them. And the future? It's already here. More.

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Subscribe with the reader of your choice
About the blogger
JeffJeff Brooks, creative director at TrueSense Marketing, has been serving the nonprofit community for more than 20 years and blogging about it since 2005. He considers fundraising the most noble of pursuits and hopes you'll join him in that opinion. You can reach him at jeff.brooks [at] truesense [dot] com. More.

Blog policies
TrueSense logo
Instead of talking at donors, TrueSense is proving it's smarter to listen. Asking donors how they prefer to give. Because we’re about creating relationships and building trust and communicating honestly and powerfully. One to one. Want to talk fundraising? Drop me a line.
Writing for fundraisers

Words2Moneybook Admit it: Fundraising writing is weird.

So many people get thrown into the work of writing fundraising without ever being told about the weird they need to live with -- and master -- if they're going to succeed.

Until now. How to Turn Your Words into Money: The Master Fundraiser's Guide to Persuasive Writing by Jeff Brooks, is specifically and tightly aimed at helping you write better fundraising. Including things like ...
  • Specifically how to ask.
  • How to use rhyme to make your message more memorable and persuasive.
  • How to tell stories that motivate donors to give.
  • How to meet donors' emotional needs.
  • Whether you should use guilt as a motivator.
Whether you're working on your very first fundraising writing assignment or you're a seasoned veteran ... whether you want it for yourself or need to show someone else how the pros write fundraising -- or both -- this is a book you should order today.
Irresistible fundraising!
TheFundraisersGuide Raise funds with your eyes open. Skip the guesswork. Show your boss what really works. This book takes you on a fact-filled and memorable journey through writing, design, strategy, and the mental game of effective fundraising.

Proven, tested, real-life techniques that give donors what they want so they can make the donations you need. If you care about fundraising, about your donors, and about supporting your cause, you need The Fundraiser's Guide to Irresistible Communications by Jeff Brooks. Order it today from Amazon.

Branding can boost fundraising

MoneyRaisingNonprofitBrand Discover how to make branding improve your fundraising in The Money-Raising Nonprofit Brand: Motivating Donors to Give, Give Happily, and Keep on Giving. It's easier -- and less expensive -- than you may think! If your organization is even vaguely considering "branding work," you need to read The Money-Raising Nonprofit Brand by Jeff Brooks. Read more here.

Popular series

stupid nonprofit ads

Uncle Maynard's

Jeff's Inferno

Blog powered by Typepad