A common fundraising strategy is to keep getting more and more new donors, without building stronger relationship with the donors you already have.
That is a quick path to failure.
You should be building your relationships with the donors you have -- maximizing what they have to offer. When you do that, your acquisition efforts will lead to growth. If you don't, you'll find yourself in a constant state of very expensive churn.
Michael Rosen's blog offers some good ways to get the balance right, at 6 Ways to Raise More Money without New Donors:
- Ask for More.
- Second Gift Appeal.
- Recruit Monthly Donors.
- Get a Challenge Grant.
- Retain Donors.
- Ask for Planned Gifts.
All these things fall under two of the three prongs of effective fundraising:
- Keep: retain the donors you already have
- Lift: encourage your donors to give more, either by giving more often or giving higher amounts
(The first prong is Win: acquire new donors.)
That's how you succeed at fundraising.